The Absence of the End of Absence
In Michael Harris’ well written and researched book,
The End of Absence (Penguin, 2014) he
explores the startlingly obvious truth that adults today over the age of 30
(roughly) are the last living witnesses to life both before
and after the Internet and our current
state of connectivity. We are the “straddle generation.”
Anyone born now or in
the last ten years can only know the
wired world. I’m 71, and I‘ve lived more
than half of my life without any kind of computer or hand held device. And, like the rest of us today I’m mired in
all that owning a smart phone means. I am one of those 10 million scratching
and clawing to be the first to purchase the newest IPhone. It’s a cliché to say
that the world has changed in every way.
Harris lays down a charge to those of us who know both
worlds. “Write about your experiences,”
he prompts. We are the last who can so testify.
It’s not about comparing the “old ways with the new ways,” but it is
about reflecting on the differences in ordinary lives. “If we’re the last people in history to know
life before the Internet, we are also the only ones who will ever speak, as it
were, both languages. We are the only
fluent translators of Before and After.
A central hope in reading his book was to get to the last
chapters in which I’d imagined he would give us some tips about how to manage this
brave new world which has so little spaciousness or solitude in it. He conducts an experiment to document his
quest: he goes on a 30 day digital blackout, sharing daily notes of his
experience during this “no email, no Internet time.” Curiously (or perhaps predictably) there is
hardly a line in this section during the unhooked days when he mentions
anything other than his longing or anxiety
with the desire to check his email or something. His diary seems to be all about thoughts of
this withdrawal. Oddly there is a total ABSENCE of ABSENCE experienced (or at
least recorded in these diary entries.)
What this points out is we don’t reclaim that spaciousness
simply by turning off the gizmos when we allow our tech addiction anxiety to
fill up the spaces now available. What
Harris misses illustrating in his month off the grid is what it might feel like
to take advantage of the new found time.
What might it be like to dive into our ordinary daily experience (not
just those mountain vista moments) and really live the moment. I think that
is what we have lost (if we ever had it) the capacity to engage and appreciate
our lives. Emily in Our Town got it right: “Oh, earth, you are too wonderful for anybody to realize you. Do any
human beings ever realize life while they live it--every, every minute?”
Harris’ final lines:
“Every technology will alienate you from some part of your life. That is
its job. Your job is to notice. First
notice the difference. And then, every
time, choose.” (p. 206) This, while an
obvious injunction, is finally his only real advice.
So, if we can’t bring back solitude or spaciousness as a
fact of life, our single modicum of control is our attention. We can notice how long we’ve been staring at
a screen. “ Then, every time,
choose.”
Then, . . . .every time . . . . choose.
Then . . .every time. . . choose.
(I’m running out of ways to be emphatic!)
This advice takes us back to Thoreau
and his intention of deliberateness. “I
went into the woods because I wanted to live deliberately.”
I think there are two issues here. One is deliberateness. The other is mindfulness.
Once we have chosen to be in our skins and live the moment
we are in currently we still need to discover how to relish the moment., how
to live and appreciate the ordinary world we inhabit.
I am reminded of a story from forty years ago. I think it speaks to the second point.
The Penn State Walk
My second
University teaching job was at Penn State University in State College,
Pennsylvania. As an Assistant Professor in Theatre Arts I had a lot on my
mind. I remember one particularly
stressful day in the fall of my second year of teaching in 1976. It was just after a fast lunch in the school
cafeteria and I was walking at a rapid clip across the campus, rushing to the
Theatre Arts Building for my three o’clock class. I was in high gear. My mind was racing with a growing sense of
panic. The inner monologue was something
like this: “And when I get to the
office I’d better photocopy the class exercise sheets, and then after the Voice class I have to go to rehearsal until 9:00
PM, and then I have to pick up the
dry cleaning before it closes, and then
I have to drop off the books at the library, and then I have to be sure to remember to call Ellen about tomorrow’s
lecture, and then I have to get gas,
and then. .
.” My mind had become a “demon
date book,” barking at me. As my
frustration mounted, I tripped slightly on the path, and suddenly I heard a
voice somewhere inside my head, speaking quite calmly and clearly: “Patricia,
PATRICIA, did you know that all you have to do right now is walk to the Theatre Arts building? So, why not just do that?”
Wow. YES!
That’s true, I thought. All I can do right now is walk to the
building. I can’t actually do the
photocopying or any of the other tasks I was listing in my litany of “things I
had to do.” All I can do RIGHT NOW is
walk. Why not do that really well? Just walk to class.
It was as if I had woken up suddenly. I slowed down and began looking around at the
colorful fall maples lining the path.
What lovely trees! As I walked, I noticed the beauty of the campus; I
felt the crisp fall air brush my cheeks, I noticed the other people on the
path, all hurrying, too. All at once I
was simply living that walk. I can still
remember everything about the scene and this was forty years ago. All I was
doing at that moment was walking to my office and living the day.
The End of Absence
message is a wake up call, not so much to simply putdown our digital toys, but
to find a way to learn to cherish the life we have. Remember Emily’s exclamation. Can we learn how to live every minute?
Thank you, Michael Harris. You wrote an important book.